Revision history [back]

Looking on google, I see the same information - "Whitehall is a village located in the town of Whitehall in Washington County, New York, United States". This is indeed unusual! I asked ChatGPT: Does the address 84 broadway whitehall new york belong to the village or the town of Whitehall?

Response: The address 84 Broadway, Whitehall, New York belongs to the Village of Whitehall, which is within the Town of Whitehall. The village is a part of the town but is a separate municipal entity with its own local government.

Looking at the defining characteristics of <city> mention, the village meets 2 out of 3: 1. it has some form of government 2. it has clearly defined geographic boundaries

So, even though it is located in the town of Whitehall, it should be tagged as <city>

Correct Annotation:

locations:get_directions -- navigate [eight four]<building_number_destination> [broadway]<street_destination> [whitehall]<city_destination> [new york]<admin1_destination>

Looking on google, I see the same information - "Whitehall is a village located in the town of Whitehall in Washington County, New York, United States". This is indeed unusual! I asked ChatGPT: Does the address 84 broadway whitehall new york belong to the village or the town of Whitehall?

Response: The address 84 Broadway, Whitehall, New York belongs to the Village of Whitehall, which is within the Town of Whitehall. The village is a part of the town but is a separate municipal entity with its own local government.

Looking at the defining characteristics of <city> mention, the village meets 2 out of 3: 1. 3:

1. it has some form of government
2.
2. it has clearly defined geographic boundaries

So, even though it is located in the town of Whitehall, it should be tagged as <city>

Correct Annotation:

locations:get_directions -- navigate [eight four]<building_number_destination> [broadway]<street_destination> [whitehall]<city_destination> [new york]<admin1_destination>