Not sure how to deal with a village/town located in the township.

asked 2024-07-23 06:51:04 +0000

Vanessa
1 ●47 ●68 ●89

Utterance:

navigate eight four broadway whitehall new york

Question:

We found the definition of "Whitehall" in google search. "Whitehall is a village located in the town of Whitehall in Washington County, New York, United States." We know that "the town of Whitehall" should be tagged as <city>, but no sure whether whitehall(village) should be tagged as <city> or <city_district>. The guideline shows "The <city> mention is for cities, municipalities, villages, towns and other city-like entities.", but we also found "The defining characteristics of acity are that they have some form of government and clearly defined geographic boundaries and are not part of another larger city." in the next paragraph. So we are not sure if "Whitehall" belongs to a larger city (the town of Whitehall). Kindly tell us your thoughts, thanks very much~

answered 2024-07-31 08:09:08 +0000

Jacqui
1 ●194 ●5

updated 2024-07-31 08:09:28 +0000

Looking on google, I see the same information - "Whitehall is a village located in the town of Whitehall in Washington County, New York, United States". This is indeed unusual! I asked ChatGPT: Does the address 84 broadway whitehall new york belong to the village or the town of Whitehall?

Response: The address 84 Broadway, Whitehall, New York belongs to the Village of Whitehall, which is within the Town of Whitehall. The village is a part of the town but is a separate municipal entity with its own local government.

Looking at the defining characteristics of <city> mention, the village meets 2 out of 3:

it has some form of government
it has clearly defined geographic boundaries

So, even though it is located in the town of Whitehall, it should be tagged as <city>

Correct Annotation:

locations:get_directions -- navigate [eight four]<building_number_destination> [broadway]<street_destination> [whitehall]<city_destination> [new york]<admin1_destination>

edit flag offensive delete link

add a comment

Your Answer

Please start posting anonymously - your entry will be published after you log in or create a new account. This space is reserved only for answers. If you would like to engage in a discussion, please instead post a comment under the question or an answer that you would like to discuss

Add Answer

Not sure how to deal with a village/town located in the township.

1 Answer

Your Answer

Question Tools

Stats

Not sure how to deal with a village/town located in the township. edit

1 Answer

Your Answer

Question Tools

Stats

Not sure how to deal with a village/town located in the township.